|
|
 |
Verdi: I Masnadieri |
| |
|
|
Artist:
Montserrat Caballé Carlo Bergonzi Piero Cappuccilli Ruggero Raimondi New Philharmonia Orchestra Lamberto Gardelli
Average Customer Rating:     
List Price: £19.99
Our Price: £11.81
|
|
|
|
Binding: Audio CD EAN: 0028947587033 Format: Box set Label: Universal Classics Manufacturer: Universal Classics Number Of Discs: 1 Publisher: Universal Classics Release Date: 2007-07-16 Running Time: 127 Studio: Universal Classics |
|
|
|
Disc 1: | 1. Overture (Preludio) - New Philharmonia Orchestra, Norman Jones, Lamberto Gardelli | | 2. Scena: "Quando io leggo in Plutarco" - Carlo Bergonzi, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 3. Aria: "O mio castel paterno" - Carlo Bergonzi, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 4. Scena: "Ecco un foglio" - Carlo Bergonzi, William Elvin, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 5. Cabaletta: "Nell'argilla maledetta" - Carlo Bergonzi, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 6. Recitativo: "Vecchio! spiccai da te" - Piero Cappuccilli, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 7. Aria: "La sua lampada vitale" - Piero Cappuccilli, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 8. Scena: "Trionfo, trionfo!" - Piero Cappuccilli, John Sandor, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 9. Cabaletta: "Tremate o miseri" - Piero Cappuccilli, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 10. Scena: "Venerabile o padre" - Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 11. Cavatina: "Lo sguardo avea degli angeli" - Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 12. Recitativo: "Mio Carlo..." - Ruggero Raimondi, Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 13. Duettino: "Carlo! io muoio..." - Ruggero Raimondi, Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 14. Finale: a) Scena: "Un messeggero" - Ruggero Raimondi, Piero Cappuccilli, Montserrat Caballé, John Sandor, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 15. Finale: b) Quartetto: "Sul capo mio colpevole" - Ruggero Raimondi, Piero Cappuccilli, Montserrat Caballé, John Sandor, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 16. Scena: "Dall'infame banchetto" - Montserrat Caballé, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 17. Aria: "Tu del mio Carlo" - Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 18. Scena: "Ah, signora!" - Montserrat Caballé, John Sandor, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 19. Cabaletta: "Carlo vive?" - Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 20. Scena: "Perché fuggisti" - Piero Cappuccilli, Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 21. Duetto: "Io t'amo, Amalia" - Piero Cappuccilli, Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 22. Scena: "Tracotante!" - Piero Cappuccilli, Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 23. Cabaletta: "Ti scosta, o malnato" - Piero Cappuccilli, Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 24. Scena e Coro: "Tutto quest'oggi" - Carlo Bergonzi, William Elvin, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 25. Recitativo: "Come splendido" - Carlo Bergonzi, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 26. Romanza: "Di ladroni attorniato" - Carlo Bergonzi, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 27. Finale: "Capitano!" - Carlo Bergonzi, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli |
Disc 2: | 1. Scena: "Dio, ti ringrazio!" - Carlo Bergonzi, Montserrat Caballé, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 2. Duetto: "Qual mare, qual terra" - Carlo Bergonzi, Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 3. Scena: "Qui nel bosco?" - Carlo Bergonzi, Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 4. Cabaletta: "Lassù risplendere" - Carlo Bergonzi, Montserrat Caballé, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 5. Coro: "Le rube, gli stupri" - The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 6. Finale: a) Scena: "Ben giunto, o Capitano!" - Carlo Bergonzi, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 7. Finale: b) Scena: "Tutto è buio e silenzio" - Ruggero Raimondi, Carlo Bergonzi, John Sandor, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 8. Finale: c) Racconto: "Un ignoto" - Ruggero Raimondi, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 9. Finale: d) Scena: "Destatevi, o pietre!" - Carlo Bergonzi, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 10. Sogno: a) "Tradimento!" - Piero Cappuccilli, John Sandor, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 11. Sogno: b) "Pareami che sorto" - Piero Cappuccilli, John Sandor, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 12. Scena e Duetto: "M'hai chiamato" - Piero Cappuccilli, Maurizio Mazzieri, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 13. Scena: "Francesco! mio figlio!" - Ruggero Raimondi, Carlo Bergonzi, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 14. Duetto: "Come il bacio d'un padre" - Ruggero Raimondi, Carlo Bergonzi, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 15. Finale: a) Scena: "Qui son essi!" - Ruggero Raimondi, Carlo Bergonzi, Montserrat Caballé, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli | | 16. Finale: b) Terzetto: "Caduto è il reprobo!" - Carlo Bergonzi, Montserrat Caballé, The Ambrosian Singers, New Philharmonia Orchestra, Lamberto Gardelli |
|
|
    Verdi rediscovery, 2007-08-23 Comment: There aren't many studio recordings of Verdi's eleventh opera - just two in fact. On Decca you can hear Dame Joan Sutherland and Franco Bonisolli as Amalia and Carlo, with Matteo Manguerra as Francesco and Samuel Ramey as Massimiliano. Philips, however, have to my mind the more effective cast. Montserrat Caballe and Carlo Bergonzi are very effective as Amalia and Carlo, and Piero Cappuccilli and Ruggero Raimondi can't be bettered.
Amalia was written for the Swedish Nightingale, Jenny Lind, and as such the role has an awful lot of trills and other fioriture that Verdi didn't normally write. Caballe has a very light and agile voice, which seems to be in keeping with Lind - the role keeps to the middle and higher registers of the soprano voice. She is particularly astounding in the opening aria, "Lo sguardo avea degli angeli", which has seemingly effortless decorations.
Carlo Bergonzi is the classic Verdi tenor, and while in parts he seems to be losing his voice (particularly in the act three finale, when a lot of punch is needed in the manner of Domingo) his opening aria, with its martial cabaletta "Nell'agila maledetta", is superb. He is also very beautiful in the act four duet with Raimondi, "Come d'un bacio d'un padre amoroso".
Piero Cappuccilli is likewise the classic Verdi baritone, bringing a lot of Italianate warmth to the role. Sounds odd, bringing warmth to a villain, but Francesco Moor has a lot of really great tunes, and Cappuccilli's voice surrounds them in his burnished tones. He is particularly magnificent in the duet with Caballe in act two, "Io t'amo, Amalia", which is itself a piece with a lot of dramatic shortcomings, but the two make it one of the high points. His opening aria, "La sua lampada vitale" has a lot of menace but also cannot escape the suavite of Cappuccilli's delivery, making Francesco more than just the blustering baritone villain. It's a shame Gardelli directs this aria with a little too much speed, making little difference between the slow and fast movements of the double-aria. The 'racconto' in Act Four and subsequent duet with Moser is also worth mentioning as truly fine singing.
Ruggero Raimondi is a magnificent basso cantante, with more than enough depth when needed. His Massimiliano has a lot of gravitas but also that necessary Italianate quality, making what must be a great approximation of the role's creator, the renowned Luigi Lablache. It's a shame there isn't more for him to do, really. There are two beautiful duets, in act one with Caballe and in act four with Bergonzi, and a short romanza in act three, "Un'ignoto, tre lune", which doesn't have a lot of scope to show Raimondi to his greatest.
Of the minor roles Maurizio Mazzieri's Moser should be mentioned. Despite the brevity of the role - one four-minute duetto with Cappuccilli is it - he has a voice of the profundo style similar to Nicolai Ghiaurov, making the duet an obvious forerunner to the Inquisitor-Filippo scene in Don Carlos of 20 years later. The chorus has some entertaining moments, including a complex scene in act two, but the Ambrosian Singers are as impeccable as ever.
The only flaw I can think of is the sound - sometimes the orchestra is too much in the foreground and so drowns the voices to a degree. But thankfully this doesn't always happen. The good points far outweight the bad, and at the re-issue price there is only really one thing left to say: Buy this opera now!
|
|